Conversation with Dan T last week - we agreed there's not enough Who songs in the ESD. Dan got on the job pretty quickly and tabbed "Can't Explain" - my end of the bargain was tabbing Substitute. I'd have had it done earlier in the week, but I managed to get a few days work stripping and re-decorating a kitchen - a BIG kitchen, so by the time I'd done a day's work, got home, eaten and showered, I've been too tired to do anything. Hardly touched a guitar all week. BUT - I've made up for it tonight. So here's my latest contribution.....
Substitute - The Who
This is a song I've been playing for a long time; no one actually told me it was quite a hard song
to play, so I went and worked it out anyway! I actually phoned a friend to find out how he played
the intro riff - which is also used in the chorus - and he e-mailed me with what sounds like a
pretty accurate tab for those parts. The main part of the song is pretty easy - you'll only need
four chords, D (plus a hammer-on for a D6 chord) G A and Em. The rest of is all what I think of
as "twiddly bits" - little riffs and fills that'll take a bit of practise, but once you get 'em
right, it'll sound great!
So - let's start at the very beginning, that's a very good place to start. Ummm, sorry, I had a
Maria von Trapp moment there - but she is right, when all's said and done!
INTRO (and let's call this riff#1, as we'll be using it again....)
This sounds pretty close.... D* D A/D G/D D D D* D A/D G/D D D
E |-5--2--5---3-3--2-2-|-5--2--5---3-3--2-2---|
B |-7--3--5---3-3--3-3-|-7--3--5---3-3--3-3---|
G |-7--2--6---4-4--2-2-|-7--2--6---4-4--2-2---|
D |-0--0--0---0-0--0-0-|-0--0--0---0-0--0-0---|
A |--------------------|----------------------|
E |--------------------|----------------------|
Now that may look pretty daunting, but don't let the quick changes put you off - basically, all you
need to do is put a half-barre across the top three (G B and E) strings with your first finger. The
first chord - D* - is that half barre, plus your ring and pinky on the G and B strings. For the
second chord - D - you slide the index finger down to the second fret, keeping the same half-barre
shape, and use your middle finger on the B string. For the A/D chord, move the half-barre up to the
fifth fret and put your ring finger on the G string; for the G/D chord, keep exactly the same shape
and move it down two frets; then move the half-barre back down to the 2nd fret and play the D chord
twice.
Have a good practise at this before moving on - it's a bit tricky at first, takes a bit of getting
used to but honestly, once you get it you really will sound like a proper guitarist! Make sure to
let that open D string ring out, though....and either mute or miss out the bottom two strings.
OK, after the intro, there's a short pause before the song comes in; I think Pete T. just plays D
chords here, but there IS a way to flesh out the song a little, especially if you're playing this
solo on an acoustic guitar. Try this: D D6 D D D6 D D D6 D D D6 D D D D6 D
E |-2--2--2--2---2--2--2---2--2--2---2--2--2--2--2--2---|
B |-3--3--3--3---3--3--3---3--3--3---3--3--3--3--3--3---|
G |-2--4--2--2---4--2--2---4--2--2---4--2--2--2--4--2---|
D |-0--0--0--0---0--0--0---0--0--0---0--0--0--0--0--0---|
A |-x--x--x--x---x--x--x---x--x--x---x--x--x--x--x--x---|
E |-x--x--x--x---x--x--x---x--x--x---x--x--x--x--x--x---|
d d u d d u d d u d d u d u d u
....and let's call this fill#1, as it'll come in handy during the verses.
So, to start with, play riff#1, then play fill#1 TWICE. Then the vocals come in:
Verse 1....
(D)You think we (G)look pretty good to(D)gether, (play fill#1 here)
(D)You think my (G)shoes are made of (D)leather, (play fill#1 here)
Next comes the pre-chorus; if you're not that great at changing chords quickly, you can just about
get away with strumming an Em chord throughout this next section; but, in the interest of adding a
little variety, here's a couple of ways to spice it up.
Firstly, you can try it with partial chords on the bottom three strings; that'll sound pretty much
like what Pete T's doing. If you're playing the song on electric guitar, the rest of the song's
pretty clean, but it sounds like he's using a little overdrive on this section. To my ears, anyway! Em G D/F#
E |----------------| (The whole of the)
B |----------------| (pre-chorus section)
G |----------------| (is just this riff,)
D |----2-----0-----| (almost to the very)
A |----2--2--0-----| (end when it changes)
E |-0--0--3--2-----| (to A & Asus4.)
Secondly, if you're playing it on acoustic, it's (IMO) better to use full chords.
This couldn't be much easier: first, hit the open E string, then play Em G D (with or without the
F# in the bass, that's up to you!) Em G D(F#)
E |----0--3--2-----|
B |----0--0--3-----|
G |----0--0--2-----|
D |----2--0--0-----|
A |----2--2--0-----|
E |-0--0--3--2-----|
Putting either of these riffs together with the lyrics, it should sound something like this:
Pre-chorus 1.....
But I'm a (Em)substi(G)tute (D) for a(Em)nother (G)guy, (D)
I (Em)look pretty (G)tall (D)but my (Em)heels are (G)high, (D)
The (Em)simple things you (G)see are (D)all (Em)compli(G)cated, (D)
I (Em)look (G)pretty (D)young but I'm (Em)just backdated (A)yeah,(Asus4)(A)
Now here comes what I find to be the trickiest bit of the whole song....the change from an open
A chord back to riff#1 for the chorus. From x02220 to xx0775 - there's no easy way around it.
But....if you can play the A chord with your first finger across the D G and B strings, that'll
get you half-way there - you just have to move that mini-barre up to the fifth fret across the top
three strings and throw your ring and pinky on as quickly as possible. Anyway, here's the chorus -
refer back to riff#1 for the fingerings and chord designations.
Chorus 1.....
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, your (G/D)lies for (D)facts,
I (D*)see (D)right (A/D)through your (G/D)plastic (D)mac,
I (D*)look (D)all (A/D)white but my (G/D)dad was (D)black,
My (D*)fine-(D)lookin' (A/D)suit's really (G/D)made out of (D)sack.
Brief pause - hold that last note for a couple of beats.
Play fill#1 once.
Verse 2.....
(D)I was born with a (G)plastic spoon in (D)my mouth, (play fill#1 here)
The north side of my town faced east and the east was facing south. (play fill#1 here)
Pre-chorus 2....
And now you (Em)dare to (G)look (D)me (Em)in the (G)eye,(D)
Those (Em)crocodile (G)tears (D)I (Em)watch you (G)cry,(D)
It's a (Em)genuine (G)prob(D)lem (Em)you won't (G)try,(D)
To (Em)work it out at (G)all (D)just (Em)pass it by, pass it (A)by,(Asus4)(A)
Chorus (2)
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, (G/D)me for (D)him,
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, my (G/D)coke for (D)gin,
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, you (G/D)for my (D)mum,
At (D*)least (D)I'll (A/D)get my (G/D)washing (D)done....
Play fill#1, then we're into the solo. Well - when I say solo, what you actually play are the same
chords as the verse....D, G, D, D, G and D. There is a way to add a little variety to this as well
if you're playing it on acoustic, though....simply incorporate Entwhistle's bass line into the
chords. Like so...... D G D D
E |-2--2--2--2---3--3--3--3---2--2--2--2---2--2--2--2---| (play)
B |-3--3--3--3---0--0--0--0---3--3--3--3---3--3--3--3---| (this)
G |-2--2--2--2---0--0--0--0---2--2--2--2---2--2--2--2---| (riff)
D |-0--0--0--0---0--0--0--0---0--0--0--0---0--0--0--0---| (twice)
A |-0--0--0--0---2--3--2--3---0--0--0--0---0--0--0--0---|
E |-2--3--2--3---3--3--3--3---2--3--2--3---2--3--2--3---|
All we're doing there is alternating between F# and G for the bass note in the D chords, and
between a C and a D note in the G chords. Another way of doing this, although it won't sound quite
as good, would be to play D and Dsus4 chords in place of the D/F# and D/G chords respectively, and
substitute (oops!) G and Gsus4 chords for the G chords.
Phew! Quick pause for breath if you've managed to get this far....the rest is plain sailing.
Everything you do from here on in is just a replay of something you've already played....
Next bit....repeat the first pre-chorus.
But I'm a (Em)substi(G)tute (D) for a(Em)nother (G)guy, (D)
I (Em)look pretty (G)tall (D)but my (Em)heels are (G)high, (D)
The (Em)simple things you (G)see are (D)all (Em)compli(G)cated, (D)
I (Em)look (G)pretty (D)young but I'm (Em)just backdated (A)yeah,(Asus4)(A)
Now repeat the intro riff - TWICE. D* D A/D G/D D D D* D A/D G/D D D
E |-5--2--5---3-3--2-2-|-5--2--5---3-3--2-2---|
B |-7--3--5---3-3--3-3-|-7--3--5---3-3--3-3---|
G |-7--2--6---4-4--2-2-|-7--2--6---4-4--2-2---|
D |-0--0--0---0-0--0-0-|-0--0--0---0-0--0-0---|
A |--------------------|----------------------|
E |--------------------|----------------------|
Quick pause - hold the last note for a couple of beats, then repeat verse two, pre-chorus 2,
chorus 2 and finish with chorus 1...
(D)I was born with a (G)plastic spoon in (D)my mouth, (play fill#1 here)
The north side of my town faced east and the east was facing south. (play fill#1 here)
Pre-chorus 2....
And now you (Em)dare to (G)look (D)me (Em)in the (G)eye,(D)
Those (Em)crocodile (G)tears (D)I (Em)watch you (G)cry,(D)
It's a (Em)genuine (G)prob(D)lem (Em)you won't (G)try,(D)
To (Em)work it out at (G)all (D)just (Em)pass it by, pass it (A)by,(Asus4)(A)
Chorus (2)
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, (G/D)me for (D)him,
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, my (G/D)coke for (D)gin,
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, you (G/D)for my (D)mum,
At (D*)least (D)I'll (A/D)get my (G/D)washing (D)done....
Chorus 1.....
(D*)Sub(D)sti(A/D)tute, your (G/D)lies for (D)facts,
I (D*)see (D)right (A/D)through your (G/D)plastic (D)mac,
I (D*)look (D)all (A/D)white but my (G/D)dad was (D)black,
My (D*)fine-(D)lookin' (A/D)suit's really (G/D)made out of (D)sack.
Phew - and another deep breath! Any questions, feel free to ask...
:D :D :D
Vic
"Sometimes the beauty of music can help us all find strength to deal with all the curves life can throw us." (D. Hodge.)
Very nicely done Vic! :D I like the extra fills or "twiddly bits" as you call them. 8)
As they say at the concerts; Who, Who, Who, Who, Who! :twisted:
Dan
"The only way I know that guarantees no mistakes is not to play and that's simply not an option". David Hodge
Good work there Vic,
Well broken up and explained.
Chris
The guitar is all right John but you'll never make a living out of it! (John Lennon's Aunt Mimi)
Just an afterthought (as suggested by jase36 and Dan T) - I recorded myself playing this as practise for some possible open mic nights. I've played it pretty much exactly as I tabbed it out.....
Jase said the video clip helped him sort out the fingerings for the intro riff - it's always nice to get feedback like that!
:D :D :D
Vic
"Sometimes the beauty of music can help us all find strength to deal with all the curves life can throw us." (D. Hodge.)
Good rendition there Vic,
Loved it!
The others a very good too especially "Behind Blue Eyes" I would say you must go open miccing ASAP
Chris
The guitar is all right John but you'll never make a living out of it! (John Lennon's Aunt Mimi)
A Classic.