My guitar teacher showed me that one way to get a minor sounding melody is to play a major scale one step down. For example: Basic 12 bar blues in E (Chords E7 A7 B7), it sounds nice to use the Eminor blues scale or pentatonics (we all know that). However, tt also sounds really good to use the D Major scale (but focus on the E as the tonal center). I just don't understand why it works.
Are you sure he didn't say three frets down? That's the usual... because then the chord progression is in E, and your solo is in C# minor (the relative minor of E)
If you move down two, you're working from the b7 of the scale. Moving the Em pentatonic down to D gives you:
D-F-G-A-C-D. You'd have the root note of the IV chord (A)... but no notes at all in the I or V, so it would be really tough to resolve - although you could end on F I suppose, making a suspension.
What's got me confused is how you'd focus on E as the tonal center when E isn't in the scale!
Guitar teacher offering lessons in Plainfield IL
In the example you cite, when you play the D major scale but use E as the tonal center, you are playing the E Dorian mode (E, F#, G, A, B, C#, D). Dorian modes are primarily minor in mood. You'll note that if you make triads out of this mode, you'll have the following:
E, G, B, which is Em
F#, A, C#, which is F#m
G, B, D, which is G major
A, C#, E, which is A major
B, D, F#, which is Bm
C#, E, G, which is C# diminished
D, F#, A, which is D major
Dorian modes are often the choice when you have a song that moves between a minor tonic and a Major IV chord. Using this example, a song that switches between Em and A major. Using the Em pentatonic (E, G, A, B, D) you lose the C# and F# which add so much to the color of this particular mode.
If you're playing blues in E (E, A and B) and you use the Dorian mode, you'll by working the typical blue notes (G and D for the E chord and D and A for the B chord), but you'll also be stressing the C# with the A chord. It makes it a little more flavorful than the straight pentatonic. It's not the norm, but it definitely can work.
This is a truly simple explanation, but I hope it helps.
Peace
LOL I mis-read the post and thought you were moving the minor pentatonic or the blues scale... the D major scale works completely, because the E minor pentatonic is a subset of it:
D-E-F#-G-A-B-C#-D
The only added notes are F# and C#, which are both also in the key of E major.
Guitar teacher offering lessons in Plainfield IL