Another tuning question for dummies

In 12TET (the technical term for our tuning system - twelve tone equal temperament) there's no difference between F# and Gb. So your tuning is just a half step down, and whoever tabbed it out doesn't have a clue for what notes should be called.

But tuning to 450Hz isn't the answer. That's simply the point where the pitch is getting closer to Bb than it is to A... it doesn't mean it's a Bb, which would be 466.164Hz.

Since your tuner only does the guitar notes, you'll have to tune fretted notes - just slap a capo on the first fret, tune as you would for standard tuning, and then take the capo off. Voila - you've dropped a half step.

Hey thanks a lot, that's the answer I was looking for. Thank you so much for the advice.

...And to think I've been playing it right the whole time!

I have the exact same tuner (or at least, I did until I left it somewhere!) and the easy answer is....

Press the "flat" button once - you should have a small "b" icon showing. Then tune to EADGBE. Each string will then be a semitone flat.....Eb, Ab, Db (shown in your tab as C#,) Gb (shown as F#,) Bb and Eb when the green light's lit up.

Tom's answer actually begs another question - how do you actually tune a guitar with a capo on? Doesn't the capo - by reason of gripping the strings - physically interfere with the whole process? The way I see it, you'd have to:

1 - pluck note with capo on.
2 - lift capo, or take it off.
3 - adjust tuning.
4 - put capo on.
5 - pluck note and repeat.....

Seems an awfully long-winded way of going about things to me....

:D :D :D

Vic

Oh, and an afterthought - I've found with this particular tuner (especially if the batteries aren't brand new, or you're tuning an acoustic through the built in mic....) that it helps if you get close to the tuning you're aiming for by ear, then fine tune with the tuner.

For your Eb-Ab-Db-Gb-Bb-Eb tuning, presuming that you're tuning down from standard EADGBE;

1 - Tune the 6th fret of the bottom E string to the open A string (doesn't have to be bang on, just close...that applies to all strings.)

2 - Tune the open A string to the 5th fret of the bottom E string

3 - Tune the open D string to the 5th fret of the A string

4 - Tune the open G string to the 5th fret of the D string

5 - Tune the open B string to the 4th fret of the G string

6 - Tune the open top E string to the 5th fret of the B string.

Now you should be fairly close - press the flat button, hit the bottom E string - it should show "6E" in the top left hand corner of your display, and if you're lucky either the green light should be showing or one of the two reds, showing you're a touch out. Fine tune it, and repeat the process for the other strings.

:D :D :D

Vic

Tom's answer actually begs another question - how do you actually tune a guitar with a capo on? Doesn't the capo - by reason of gripping the strings - physically interfere with the whole process? The way I see it, you'd have to:

1 - pluck note with capo on.
2 - lift capo, or take it off.
3 - adjust tuning.
4 - put capo on.
5 - pluck note and repeat.....

I don't really see the problem, Vic. Why would you have to take the capo off to adjust the tuning? You can still turn the pegs with the capo on. I agree that a tight capo's grip can have an effect, but it's very slight and nothing that a little tweaking can't fix when you finally take it off.

I don't really see the problem, Vic. Why would you have to take the capo off to adjust the tuning? You can still turn the pegs with the capo on. I agree that a tight capo's grip can have an effect, but it's very slight and nothing that a little tweaking can't fix when you finally take it off.

It was just a thought - I've never actually tried tuning with a capo on. I just felt that the capo would hinder the tuning process by gripping the strings (especially wound bass strings) and making it harder to tune. Could that be a sign that my capo's too tight, perhaps? It is adjustable.

:D :D :D

Vic

Quite often some fine tuning is necessary. Sometimes it's the capo and sometimes it's that the person using it doesn't place it optimally (at a slight angle instead of parallel with the fret). In theory it should be fine, and for most people's ears it is, but it's amazing that when you check it with a tuner it's often slightly off.

Of course, some people do it perfectly every time. Your mileage may vary, as they say...

Peace

sometimes it's that the person using it doesn't place it optimally (at a slight angle instead of parallel with the fret).

Really? I don't think I've ever come across that particular piece of advice before - or if I have, for some reason it's gone in through one ear and straight out the other! Which way should it be slanted?

:D :D :D

Vic

I've got to stop writing when I'm so tired. I meant that they placed the capo at an angle and not parallel to the frets. Sorry about that.

Peace

I'm really tired. I read it and understood it the way you meant it. :D

I must have been tired, too! Makes sense now....

:D :D :D

Vic